
Michael Bourn, Mike Costanzo and Geoff Geary were dealt to the Astros for Eric Bruntlett and Brad Lidge.
The obvious take is: This improves the bullpen.
Let’s break it down.
Phils Lose:
- Michael Bourn: Clearly the biggest loss of the deal. Bourn was the fourth outfielder, and a possible future starter. We’ll most miss his blinding speed (he may be the fastest guy in the game) and his fine glove. Pat Gillick better look hard for another outfielder, because if we lose Aaron Rowand, I’m not comfortable with Burrell/Victorino/Werth.
- Mike Costanzo: A top-10 prospect for us, he’s got a powerful bat but limited abilities elsewhere. I really don’t mind losing him, as the Phils don’t need another power bat with strikeout tendencies on the big club.
- Geoff Geary: Actually, this irks me a bit, as Geary could’ve filled in the 5th/6th inning role well. Of course, I believe he was either Majors or waivers, so maybe this wasn’t a bad cut.
Phils Get:
- Brad Lidge: The former All Star closer is 30 and going into his seventh year in the majors. He has saved 122 games in the past four years, but his 2006 was horrendous, as he stunk it up with a Phillie-quality 5.28 ERA. He rebounded in 2007 in a closer/setup role with a 3.36 ERA and 1.254 WHIP. He strikes out a lot of guys and if he returns to his 2004 peak, he’d be absolutely stunning in the closer role.
- Eric Bruntlett: Not known for his offense (zero homers the last two years), Bruntlett is your new Abraham Nunez. Then again, he committed eight errors in 73 games last season. That’s not exactly defensive replacement material, but his nickname is “Superman,” so we’ll see. Almost a throw in, and I suppose he’s equal to Geary in this deal.
What it means:
The Associated Press and Jerry Crasnick are saying the Brett Myers 9th inning era is done in Philadelphia, the thrilling climax being “Curve ball struck ‘im out! Phillies are 2007 National League Eastern Division champions!”
If Myers moves back to the rotation, it basically solves the rotation problem (though acquiring one of those cheap No. 4 or 5 options wouldn’t hurt). But the bullpen …
Rotation: Hamels/Myers/Moyer/Kendrick/Eaton
Bullpen: Condrey/Zagurski/Rosario (or Mateo)/Madson/Romero (or other)/Gordon/Lidge
We need someone else. I’d make the push for Francisco Cordero and drive Lidge to the 8th, pushing Gordon to a filler role and ditching Rosario.
If Myers remains the closer, the rotation still needs an arm. There’s talk of the Phils being interested in Japanese hurler Hirodi Kuroka. He’d make sense as a possible No. 2. As would my previous option, Bartolo Colon.
Rotation: Hamels/FILL/Moyer/Kendrick/Eaton
Bullpen: Condrey/Zagurski/Madson/Romero (or other)/Gordon/Lidge/Myers
We still need that LOOGY, and re-signing Romero becomes priority 1. But again, if Myers moves back to the rotation, I’m not completely comfortable with Lidge closing games. I’d like to see the team make the push for Cordero.
How’d they do?
Well, we won’t know that answer for some time, but this has the potential to be a great deal. If Lidge can at least play like he did last season, it immediately upgrades our weakest place. And we filled one of our necessities: grabbing a guy with experience who can setup in the 8th (or close in the 9th). Yes, we gave away Bourn, but the stark reality is he wasn’t starting this year. Even if the Phils lose Aaron Rowand, Jayson Werth will be in right field. In fact, this may signal that the Phils and Rowand are very close to something; if this is the case, I have no problems with losing Bourn. But if Rowand walks, it becomes a necessity to grab at least a fourth outfielder.
Mike Costanzo isn’t quite an everyday Major League player. He strikes out a ton and plays horrid defense. As a third baseman, defense is paramount; moreover, he wouldn’t be moving to first base anytime soon with what’s there now. Costanzo simply was not the third base answer for the big club. Geary could’ve been valuable in the 5th/6th innings, and maybe the Phils could’ve given up someone else, but middle relievers of Geary’s talents are a dime a dozen (we have a bunch of them).
Finally, Lidge has $6M+ coming his way in 2008, and we’ll be paying almost all of that. Not bad; we have about $14M to spend on either a starter or a reliever, Romero and another offensive bat. Should work.
For now, I give the Phillies a 5.5 on the deal. If Lidge performs well and the Phils upgrade another two pitching spots, it’s a clear win.